#48 - Contingent Self-Worth: What Is Your Worth Tied To?
What happens when your sense of worth becomes tied to achievement, approval, productivity, competence, or being needed by others?
In this episode, Dr. Cory Potter explores contingent self-worth and how it can shape the way we respond to mistakes, criticism, comparison, and disappointment. We’ll also look at practical ways to develop a healthier, more stable sense of self-worth through examining self-talk, learning from setbacks, practicing self-compassion, and focusing on the values that guide how we live.
Toward the end, we consider self-worth from a Christian perspective and what Genesis 1:26–27 tells us about the source of human worth. This conversation also sets the stage for the next episode on false idols and mental health.
0:00 Think about the last time something went really well for you. Maybe someone praised your work, you accomplished something that you had been working toward, or someone you really respect told you that you were doing a good job. Maybe what made you feel good had less to do with something you accomplished and more to do with how you felt about your appearance, feeling secure in a relationship, or realizing that you were financially in a good place. Chances are, at some point, at least some of those experiences made you feel pretty good about yourself. Now think about what happens when something in one of those areas goes the opposite direction. You make a mistake at work. Someone criticizes you. A relationship becomes sprained. Or you don't receive the recognition that you expected. Maybe someone else succeeds.
0:57 in an area where you've been struggling. Where you go through a season when you aren't able to accomplish as much as you normally do. Sometimes the way we feel about ourselves can change right along with those circumstances. And there's a psychological concept that can help us understand why that happens. It's called contingent self -worth. And once you understand what it means, you may begin recognizing it. in places that you hadn't thought about before. Welcome to Mind and Faith Matters. I'm the host, Dr. Cory Potter, and this is a place where we explore mental health, faith, and all the in -between. Today I want to talk about this from a mental health perspective, primarily. I also want to consider what this might mean from a Christian perspective. A good place to begin with is asking a fairly simple question. What has to happen for you to feel good about who you are. You see, contingent self -worth is the idea that our sense of value can become tied to certain areas of our lives. When those things go well in those areas, we may feel better about ourselves. And when they don't go well, our sense of worth can take a hit. Researchers Jennifer Cocker and Connie Wolf. have studied several areas where this can happen, including approval from other people, physical appearance,
2:30 competence, family support, morality, competition. For our conversation, I want to focus on a few that are especially easy to recognize in everyday life. Approval, competence, achievement, productivity, and being needed by other people. So let's unpack it. Caring about these things is normal. Most of us want to do well, have healthy relationships, and know that the people we care for and about value us. Accomplishing something meaningful can feel good, while failure, criticism, and rejection can hurt. at the heart of contingent self -worth is the question of how much we allow those experiences to determine how we feel about ourselves. Imagine that being competent is particularly important to you and the way you see yourself.
3:40 And you make a pretty big mistake at work. And naturally, you're likely feeling frustrated or disappointed. but then you can begin to attach additional meaning to that mistake. Your thinking can shift from, I made a mistake and I need to understand what happened, to wondering whether you're actually capable or at least as capable as you thought you were. Maybe you start worrying that other people are going to question your abilities or eventually discover you aren't as good as you thought you were or as they thought you were at your job. you begin convincing yourself the mistake has something to do with your value rather than seeing it as something that needs to be addressed. That really can affect what you do next. Think about it. You might replay what happened over and over. You may begin working longer hours because you feel like you have something to prove. You may become defensive when someone gives you feedback. Or some may even hesitate to take on something difficult because another failure feels threatening. And this is one reason that contingent self -worth can be difficult to recognize. It can sometimes sit underneath behaviors that look very positive. Someone may
5:11 be hard -working, dependable, generous. highly accomplished are always willing to help. And those qualities alone don't tell us what's driving them. Two people can work equally hard for very different reasons. Someone may enjoy doing excellent work and feel responsible for doing it well. Someone else may also care deeply about excellence while depending on success to reassure themselves that they're valuable. We can see the same thing with approval. Caring what other people think is part of living in relationships with people.
5:54 That's what makes us human. When your need for approval becomes closely tied to your self -worth though, disagreement can begin to carry more meaning than it should. You may begin to change your actions and decisions to keep people happy. The desire for approval may keep you from setting much needed boundaries, and you may find yourself spending a lot of time wondering whether someone is upset with you. And what about productivity? It can be another source of worth. Accomplishing something meaningful can be satisfying, but slowing down may become surprisingly uncomfortable when productivity is helping determine how valuable you feel. Times of rest or simply not being productive can leave you feeling guilty. And let's face it, life happens. And major changes such as retirement, job loss, illness, disability, or having to take time to care for someone can also show you how closely your sense of self has become tied to what you're able to accomplish. Let's unpack helping people and caring for people. You know, it can be very meaningful to help people and care for people as part of our lives. If being the dependable person or the person everyone
7:25 calls becomes one of the main ways you reassure yourself that you matter, boundaries may become harder for you. You may even take responsibility for problems that aren't yours. Because stepping away affects how you see yourself. And then there's comparison, of course. You can feel successful until you encounter someone who seems more successful or financially secure. And then that comparison lets you think, oh man, they have more. What about parenting? As another example, you may feel pretty confident about your parenting until another family appears to have everything figured out. Your circumstances didn't change. The standard that you were using to compare yourself with them did. Social media gives us an almost endless supply of opportunity for that kind of comparison.
8:23 We see other people's achievements, careers, relationships, homes, appearances, families, vacations, and selected moments of their lives. It's curated and we may understand that we're seeing an incomplete picture and still use it standard for our lives. And this gets at one of the problems with contingent self -worth. When our sense of worth depends heavily on meeting certain conditions, those conditions have to keep being met. An accomplishment, for example, eventually becomes something you accomplished last year. An accomplishment may only reassure you for so long. If achievement is one of the main ways you maintain your sense of worth, reaching one goal may eventually stop feeling like enough.
9:17 So you have to set another and another. There's nothing unhealthy about setting goals or wanting to accomplish more. What matters here is whether your motivation is growth and something meaningful to you or whether you need another accomplishment to keep proving your value. The standard can keep moving and we can find ourselves returning to the same areas of life again and again for reassurance. It can also make ordinary setbacks feel much more personal. There's a meaningful difference between recognizing I failed at something and concluding I'm a failure. Someone can disagree with a decision you've made without their disagreement deciding what you're worth. A day when you aren't very productive doesn't determine your value as a person for that day. We may understand those ideas when we hear them and still have trouble holding on to them when we're the person experiencing failure or criticism or rejection or disappointment.
10:30 I also don't want to attribute every struggle with perfectionism, approval, comparison, achievement, or relationships to this idea of contingent self -worth. You see, contingent self -worth gives us one way of understanding what may be happening when our view of ourselves becomes closely tied to success, performance, approval, or other sources of validation. Recognizing the pattern is useful and awareness gives us a starting point. So if you're recognizing some of this in yourself as I bring it up, You may be asking, what can I do about it? Start by paying attention to the times when your opinion of yourself changes quickly.
11:13 Instead of moving past the feeling, you should take a moment to intentionally reflect on what happened and why it affected you the way it did and the way you see yourself. Maybe someone criticized you. Maybe you did fail at something, felt rejected, or wrongfully compared yourself with somebody else. And then I want you to... Consider what you started telling yourself because of that experience. A mistake can turn into I'm incompetent. Rejection can become I'm unlovable. Someone else's success can lead you to feel like I'm falling behind. Needing help might become I should be able to handle this myself. While resting can leave you telling yourself that you're lazy.
12:01 And that kind of unhealthy self -talk can take a specific experience and turn it into a much larger statement about who you are, at least in your own mind. You can deal honestly with those things and take responsibility for them without allowing one event, one weakness, or one person's opinion to determine your value as a person. There's another part of this that can easily be missed. When we feel inadequate, we often try to restore our sense of worth by reminding ourselves of what we've accomplished, looking for reassurance, or searching for evidence that we're doing better than we thought. That may help for a while, but if we continually need evidence we're valuable, we will eventually need another accomplishment, another compliment, or more reassurance. A healthier sense of self -worth can handle experiences that don't make us feel particularly good about ourselves. And one way to develop that healthier self -worth is to focus more on learning and growth when something goes wrong. A mistake at work may show you something you need to change. Conflict in a relationship may reveal something about how you communicate that needs to improve. Criticism may contain something useful. even when you don't agree with all of it. You can ask, what can I learn from
13:35 this, before deciding what the experience says about you. It still leaves room for ambition, high standards, and doing excellent work. You're learning to pursue those things without requiring the outcome to prove your value. And you may need professional help, you may need counseling help to get there, but... Practicing these things can also help you to become more comfortable with situations that challenge the particular area where you've placed your worth. If you have a self -worth that depends heavily on approval, one step may be learning that someone can disagree with you or be disappointed with the decision you made while you remain confident that the decision was reasonable and consistent with your values. If productivity determines a lot of your self -worth, you may need to practice resting or having less productive times without treating them as evidence that you are less valuable.
14:39 And if competence is especially important to your self -worth, try something new where you aren't immediately good at it. Being a beginner making mistakes or discovering that you're fairly average at something can help you experience competence as one part of your life rather than a measure of your value. And if being needed by other people is closely tied to your self -worth, pay attention to what happens internally when someone doesn't need your help or chooses to handle something on their own. The point here isn't to become less helpful, it's to pay attention to whether helping has also become a way of reassuring yourself. that you matter. In these instances, self -compassion can also be useful. Sometimes people hear that term and it assumes or they assume that it means excusing ourselves or lowering our expectations. Self -compassion still leaves room for accountability. It means we can acknowledge failure, limitation, pain, or imperfection. and respond to ourselves with a kind of reasonable care we would often extend to someone else. Think about someone you respect coming to you after making a genuine mistake. You wouldn't need to pretend the mistake didn't matter. You also probably wouldn't decide that one mistake tells you everything
16:10 you need to know about that person's value. We can learn to extend that same fairness and grace to ourselves. Another useful shift you can make is paying close attention to outcomes and the values you want to live by. We care about outcomes, but we don't completely control them, if you think about it. You can prepare extremely well for an interview and still not get the job. You can put considerable effort into a relationship while the other person makes choices you can't control. You can do excellent work and someone may still criticize it. So along with asking yourself did something turn out the way you hoped Considered how you handled things that didn't go the way you wanted and here are some questions that you can ask yourself about your Activity in your response. Did you act with integrity?
17:06 Did you treat people well? Did you put reasonable effort into what you were doing? Were you willing to learn and take responsibility? when you needed to. Those are things we have more influence over, and they give us a healthier way to evaluate our choices when the outcome isn't what we hoped for. And over time, these practices can help our sense of worth become more stable. Achievement can be meaningful without determining your value. Approval can feel good without requiring everyone to approve of us. Relationships can matter deeply without requiring another person to continually reassure us that we matter. And we can care deeply about these parts of our lives without giving them the job of telling us what we're worth.
18:06 So as a believer, I want to talk about how Christians may deal with this. There's another part of the conversation because scripture gives us a reason for believing human worth. already there. In the Bible, the book of Genesis chapter 1 verses 26 and 27, we're told that human beings are created in the image of God. Our dignity and worth come from God because we bear His image. We don't become valuable because we're successful, attractive, productive, useful, respected, or admired. And this isn't something Christians possess that everyone else doesn't. Every human being bears God's image, including the person who doesn't believe in God. I think that if we're honest with ourselves, we need to understand that being made in God's image doesn't mean everything we do is good. We still fail. We sin. We hurt people.
19:14 We make poor decisions and sometimes we need to admit that we've been wrong and we need to make things right. But none of those things changes the source of our human worth. For Christians, our relationship with God also shapes our identity, how we understand ourselves and who we're becoming. And there's much more to say about that than I want to try to fit into this episode. Once we recognize how easily achievement, approval, relationships, appearance, success, usefulness, and other things can influence our sense of self -worth, another question begins to emerge. What else am I asking these things to give me? And that's where this conversation starts moving beyond psychology. Something can begin to influence where we place our trust, where we look for security.
20:13 what receives our deepest loyalty, and ultimately how we relate to God. And that's where the subject of idolatry enters the conversation. In the next episode, we're going to look at false idols and mental health, what Scripture actually means when it talks about idolatry, and what can happen when something begins occupying a space in our lives that God intended for himself. But for now, Pay attention to what seems to have the greatest power to change the way you feel about yourself. And consider how much you rely on that part of your life to determine your value. You can care deeply about doing good work, being a good parent, having meaningful relationships, accomplishing the goals like we've talked about, taking care of yourself, and growing in the things that matter to you. Remember... Your worth doesn't have to rise and fall with how well these things are going. Thanks for spending time with me today on Mind & Faith Matters. If this episode gave you something useful to think about, maybe something to change, maybe something to discuss with a friend or a counselor, consider sharing it with someone who might appreciate the conversation.
21:40 You can also subscribe or follow the podcast wherever you listen. Until next time, take care of your mind, nurture your faith, and remember that both matter and your worth is not based on performance. God bless and have a good week.
RSS Feed